Apr. 22nd, 2021

To continue with the presentation Thursday evening (Thursday the 15th of April), Dan Sullivan said that taxes on alcohol and tobacco tend to be regressive, as do tariffs. The deed transfer tax is bad, because it poses an obstacle to transferring land (and other real estate) to the people who want to put it to its best use, while not taxing landowners so long as they don’t sell. A sales tax on necessities is bad and regressive, of course, as is a per capita tax, which hits the rich and the poor with the same tax bills.

The inheritance tax is disruptive. If a rich man has a portfolio of various stocks and bonds, his heirs can sell some of them to pay the tax, but if he has a business of his own, having to come up with money can be a problem. Dan Sullivan gave the example of a stadium-owning family, I think in Pittsburgh, where the patriarch hadn’t prepared by, for example, buying life insurance.

Any tax is regressive if the revenue is spent badly enough. For example, taxes to subsidize a sports stadium: the poor, who pay some of the taxes, watch the games at home or in a sports bar, on TV, while the well-off may buy tickets to the game, and millionaires can have their private boxes. This is a transfer of money from the poor to the rich.

In Pennsylvania, many poor communities have LVT in the form of a two-rate tax; the land value tax hits absentee owners.

There’s the ghetto effect: suppose that someone from a poor neighborhood goes to college and earns a good income (or possibly becomes a pro athlete). Living in a poor community, he’s hit with a high wage tax and building tax, since high taxes are needed to raise revenue in a place where most people have low incomes and cheap houses; therefore, he’s likely to move to a more prosperous town, where the taxes are lower. But with land value taxation, he wouldn’t pay as much for a plot of land in the poor town as in a rich town, so he’ll stay where he grew up, and contribute to the community, and help make the poor place better.

People criticize the property tax to fund local schools, etc., since poor communities need higher tax rates to raise less revenue, but that’s not really a problem with the property tax; it’s a problem with local taxes. To ameliorate the situation, at least some taxes should be imposed on a statewide or national level, and the revenue shared. (As I recall, Polly Cleveland chimed in on this.)

Dan quoted Dave Wetzel, who’s British, saying that the one good thing about a poll or per capita tax is that it got rid of Maggie Thatcher. When she tried to replace the rates (property taxes) with a poll tax, there were riots, and she was booted from office.

Cecil Rhodes in Africa wanted and got taxes on the natives, not so much to raise revenue as to force them to participate in the cash economy, and get jobs working in the mines, or for white settlers. There was discussion of how to treat indigenous people fairly. I suggested that even a land value tax, in that kind of situation, should be levied with payment in kind accepted, so as to be fair to people who didn’t want to sell their labor for cash.

The consensus was that there should be a per capita dividend (I agree). Indigenous people could live traditionally, and use their dividends to pay the taxes on their lands; or if they chose to participate in modern civilization more, they could do that.
Today I got my first COVID-19 vaccination (Moderna), and my shoulder is sore. Earlier, I felt sort of blah, and wanted to take a nap, but when I lay down, I couldn’t fall asleep, a situation which may or may not have had much to do with the shot.

I did not get the vaccine through my pre-registration with the Commonwealth of Virginia; I went to the CVS website, and, after a couple of unsuccessful attempts, managed to find an opening and register for it; the second dose is arranged for four weeks from today. The CVS half a mile or so from me isn’t doing vaccinations, but I was able to walk to one two miles away, so I got some extra exercise today.

The second shot may produce a stronger reaction than the first, but I’ll face that when the time comes; it will still very likely be less serious than getting the actual disease.
Daniel Raisbeck has an article in Reason on Latin American politics, describing how conservatism is discredited by right-wingers who don’t much respect liberty, or follow free market policies, leading to the Left coming to power, which, as can be seen in Venezuela and elsewhere, is not always a good thing for the poor and downtrodden folks whom the leftists claim to speak for.

What Senor Raisbeck does not say is that this could also apply to North America, where the party of Reagan became the party of Trump, and then lost to free-spending, pro-regulation Joe Biden. I am not happy with the direction my country seems to be taking.

Profile

ndrosen

June 2025

S M T W T F S
123 4567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 6th, 2025 01:07 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios